Crandall & Pera Law, LLC
Call 24/7 - Free Consultation

Five Commonly Held Myths of Medical Malpractice

Due to the large number of medical malpractice claims a year - for everything from mistakes in treatment to an uninformed patient - the topic has wide currency in medical circles. But can you really believe everything you read?

One can easily find common malpractice myths that are both mistaken and misleading in a variety of media, from op-eds and blog postings, to public statements by physicians of all specialties, including those designated as spokespersons for organized medicine.

The 5 Myths of Medical Malpractice are as follows:

  1. Malpractice crises are caused by spikes in medical malpractice litigation (i.e., sudden rises in payouts and claim frequency). While this may be natural to believe, both federal and state studies have found that both the frequency of malpractice claiming and the frequency of paid medical malpractice claims per physician has been dropping steadily since 1992, and is now less than one-half the level it was in 1992.

  2. The tort system delivers "jackpot justice." This basic charge is that the system doles out compensation randomly - uninjured patients take home millions, whereas those who suffer grievously receive little or nothing at all. A far larger and more realistic problem, however, is that an enormous fraction of patients who are harmed by medical negligence either make no effort to recover damages or cannot find lawyers willing to take their cases. These patients, who are entitled to compensation, never initiate claims. Thus, the liability system is simultaneously beset by overclaiming and underclaiming.

  3. Physicians are one malpractice verdict away from bankruptcy. Many physicians seem to believe that malpractice verdicts threaten to wipe out their savings. In reality, out-of-pocket payments by physicians are extraordinarily rare, particularly when physicians have policy limits of or above $500,000. When payments above the policy limits are made, whether in tried or settled cases, they almost always come from insurers.

  4. Physicians move in large numbers to states that adopt damages caps. If physicians relocate because of liability risk, damages caps are an obvious strategy for attracting more physicians, particularly in lawsuit-prone specialties. Although a nationwide cap would actually reduce relocations by making this incentive disappear, studies have shown that physician supply was not measurably stunted prior to reform, and it did not measurably improve after reform. While damages caps may play a small role in attracting and keeping physicians practicing in rural areas and in high-risk specialties, the evidence is mixed, and some studies have found no effect.

  5. Tort regorm will lower health-care spending dramatically. When it comes to the malpractice liability system, it is important to distinguish between the direct costs (cost of malpractice awards and settlements and all costs associated with defending against such claims) and indirect costs (incurred when providers take steps to reduce their perceived likelihood of being sued, such as by running extra tests). Because tort reforms make lawsuits less likely and less expensive, they may reduce defensive medicine and thereby reduce healthcare spending, but since the direct costs of the malpractice system are on the order of 2% of health-care spending, any costs would not be affected dramatically.

Damage caps do little to improve the malpractice system as they do not make healthcare safer, reduce healthcare spending, compensate those who are negligently injured, or make the liability system work better. The best reforms are patient safety initiatives that reduce the frequency and severity of medical mistakes. Ideally, the liability system would encourage providers to adopt patient-protecting innovations above everything else.

If you or a family member believe you have a medical malpractice case, contact Crandall & Pera Law today for a free case evaluation. Crandall & Pera Law is available to help answer your questions and guide you in determining your next steps.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Email Us For A Response

The Respect And Dignity You Deserve

Our dedicated team of skilled trial attorneys and registered nurses have devoted their careers to seeking justice for clients just like YOU. Please reach out to us today at 855-444-6651 or via the Internet, we are only one call or email away. An initial consultation is free and comes without strings.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Office Locations

Cincinnati Office
36 East 7th St.
Suite 2610
Cincinnati, OH 45202

Toll Free: 855-444-6651
Cincinnati Law Office Map

Cleveland Office
850 Euclid Ave.
Suite 1122
Cleveland, OH 44114

Toll Free: 855-444-6651
Cleveland Law Office Map

Columbus Office
35 E. Gay St.
Suite 226
Columbus, OH 43215

Toll Free: 855-444-6651
Columbus Law Office Map

Cincinnati Office
1095 Nimitzview Dr.
Suite 403
Cincinnati, OH 45230

Toll Free: 855-444-6651
Cincinnati Law Office Map

Chesterland Office
12768 Chillicothe Rd.
Suite 210
Chesterland, OH 44026

Toll Free: 855-444-6651
Chesterland Law Office Map

Lexington Office
1900 Cambridge Dr.
Suite 101
Lexington, KY 40504

Toll Free: 855-444-6651
Lexington Law Office Map

Chagrin Falls Office
15 1/2 N. Franklin St.
Chagrin Falls, OH 44022

Toll Free: 855-444-6651
Chagrin Falls Law Office Map